2026 LakeGeorge.com Fab Five Winners: Best Ice Cream

A visit to Lake George isn’t complete without a sweet, frozen treat. The 2026 LakeGeorge.com Fab Five results, shaped by community voting, highlight the top spots for ice cream, gelato, and frozen yogurt. This category recognizes the places serving up the most satisfying scoops and desserts across the region.

1. Martha's Dandee Creme

Claiming the top spot, Martha's Dandee Creme continues to be a beloved Lake George area tradition known for its generous portions and wide variety of ice cream flavors. Its longtime popularity and classic roadside charm make it a must-visit destination for a frozen treat.

2. Stewart's Shops

Finishing in second place, Stewart's Shops has earned a loyal following with its rich, locally made ice cream and extensive selection of flavors. Whether enjoyed in a cone, cup, or sundae, its ice cream remains a favorite throughout the region.

3. Candy Apple

Securing third place, Candy Apple in Lake George is known for offering a sweet mix of desserts and frozen treats that appeal to visitors of all ages. Its fun atmosphere and variety of options make it a popular stop for satisfying a sweet tooth.

4. Sprinkles

Landing in fourth place, Sprinkles has become a go-to destination for ice cream lovers looking for a refreshing treat on a warm day. Its selection of flavors and family-friendly atmosphere help make it a standout in the Lake George area.

5. Scoop's Ice Cream Parlor

Located right on Canada Street in the bustling center of the village, Scoop's Ice Cream Parlor serves up premium hard ice cream sourced from Wilcox Creamery. Visitors can relax at the shop's casual outdoor seating area to enjoy handmade waffle cones, thick milkshakes, and scratch-made ice cream sandwiches served in generous portions right along the main village sidewalk.

<< Back to the Fab Five Winners